top of page

Would Saint Peter and Saint Paul Approve of Selling Their Basilicas to Help the Poor?

The grandeur of the basilicas dedicated to Saints Peter and Paul stands as a testament to the enduring faith and devotion of the Church. These sacred spaces, adorned with priceless art and intricate architecture, inspire awe and elevate the soul toward God. However, a provocative question arises: would Saints Peter and Paul, men who lived humble lives and suffered martyrdom for their faith, approve of such splendour? Would they, in the spirit of Gospel simplicity, advocate for selling these basilicas and using the proceeds to aid the poor? This question challenges us to consider the balance between material resources and spiritual priorities within the Church.  

A majestic view of the Basilica of Saint Peter in Vatican City, symbolising faith and the spiritual mission of the Catholic Church.

One might wonder, particularly in the context of sacred architecture like the basilicas of Saint Peter and Saint Paul, whether the Church should sell these grand edifices and their treasures to help the poor. Could not the wealth of these magnificent buildings be converted into material assistance for those in need? This question, rooted in compassion, seems to align with the Gospel’s call to care for the poor and the vulnerable. Yet the Church teaches that such a perspective misunderstands the purpose of sacred spaces and their role in the mission of the Church.  


A closer look at Catholic teaching and the words of Jesus offers a deeper understanding of the value of sacred spaces and their role in addressing both spiritual and material poverty. Jesus Himself addressed a similar concern when Mary anointed His feet with costly perfume. When Judas Iscariot suggested that the perfume should have been sold to help the poor, Jesus replied, “The poor you always have with you, but you do not always have me” (John 12:8). On the surface, this might seem dismissive of the needs of the poor, but Jesus’ words carry profound meaning. 


Jesus does not deny the importance of helping the poor—indeed, His entire ministry demonstrates a deep concern for the marginalised and suffering. Instead, He highlights the reality that there will always be opportunities to serve the poor and emphasises the unique moment of worship and devotion in Mary’s act. This passage invites us to consider that acts of reverence and worship, including the preservation of sacred spaces, are offerings of love to God that serve a spiritual purpose. 


The Catholic Church embraces a holistic vision of charity, addressing both spiritual and material needs. Sacred spaces are not in opposition to the Church’s mission to help the poor; they are integral to it. The beauty of these spaces inspires faith and generosity, drawing the faithful closer to God and encouraging them to live out the Gospel’s call to love and serve others. Additionally, sacred spaces belong to the people of God and serve as enduring symbols of hope and faith. Selling such spaces might provide temporary relief, but it would deprive future generations of their spiritual richness and will undermine the Church’s ability to inspire and evangelise. Sacred architecture offers more than material wealth—it provides spiritual encounters that transform lives and inspires charity. Instead, the Church seeks to care for the poor while preserving the sacred, recognising that both are essential to its mission. 

 

Saints Peter and Paul, who dedicated their lives to spreading the Gospel, would likely see these basilicas not as monuments of wealth but as expressions of faith and tools for mission. While they lived simply, their ultimate goal was to bring people closer to God. Sacred architecture, when understood in its true purpose, exists not for luxury but to glorify God and inspire the faithful to live out the Gospel in their lives.


The Role of Sacred Space in Personal Faith 


Sacred spaces are essential to our spiritual journey, providing a sanctuary where we can encounter God in a tangible and transformative way. These spaces, whether humble chapels or grand basilicas, serve as places of refuge from the distractions of our daily lives, offering silence and beauty that draw our hearts and minds to prayer. The separation of the sacred from the secular in these spaces helps create an environment where we can focus entirely on our relationship with God. Sacred architecture thus serves not merely as a backdrop for prayer but as a facilitator of our profound spiritual experiences. 


The design of sacred spaces intentionally leads us on a journey. In the basilicas of Saint Peter and Saint Paul, the architecture itself tells a story. The long nave of Saint Peter’s Basilica, for example, symbolises the pilgrimage of life, guiding visitors towards the altar where Jesus Christ is truly present in the Holy Eucharist. The soaring ceilings and intricate details evoke a sense of awe and humility, reminding the faithful of God’s majesty and our dependence on His grace. Similarly, Saint Paul’s Basilica Outside the Walls includes mosaics of the apostles, connecting visitors to the apostolic foundation of the Church and inspiring them to follow in the apostles’ footsteps. 


Beyond their physical beauty, sacred spaces foster a deeper connection to the divine through sacramental worship. These spaces are designed to enhance the liturgical experience, with every detail pointing to the sacred mysteries being celebrated. For example, the placement of the altar as the focal point reminds us of the centrality of Christ’s sacrifice, while the use of light through stained glass windows creates an atmosphere of divine presence. These elements deepen our faith, offering a place to encounter Christ in a way that nourishes our soul. 


Sacred spaces also unite individual and communal worship. While they offer a personal haven for prayer, they are also places where the Catholic community gathers to celebrate the sacraments and offer collective praise to God. The shared experience of worship in a sacred space strengthens our bonds, reminding us that we are part of a universal Church. In this way, sacred spaces serve as bridges between the personal and communal dimensions of faith, fostering a sense of belonging and mission that flows outward into the world. 

 

The Feast of Dedication of the Basilicas of Saint Peter and Saint Paul


The Feast of the Dedication of the Basilicas of Saint Peter and Saint Paul is a celebration of more than just buildings; it honours the rich tradition of faith expressed through art and architecture. These basilicas are not only places of prayer but also masterpieces of human creativity, designed to glorify God and inspire the faithful. By dedicating an annual feast to these basilicas, the Church invites us to reflect on the importance of beauty in the life of faith and to consider how sacred art and architecture elevate our worship. 


Art and architecture in the Church have always been more than decorative. They serve as tools for evangelisation and education, communicating theological truths through visual and structural language. Saint Peter’s Basilica, for instance, is adorned with sculptures and paintings that depict pivotal moments in salvation history, while its grandeur reflects the universality and authority of the Church. The dome itself is a theological statement, pointing heavenward and reminding all who gaze upon it of their ultimate destination. Similarly, Saint Paul’s Basilica Outside the Walls features mosaics of the apostles and scenes from the life of Saint Paul, highlighting the missionary spirit of the Church and its apostolic foundation. 


This feast also celebrates the sacrifices and dedication that went into the creation of these sacred spaces. These basilicas were built not merely as architectural wonders but as offerings to God, created by skilled artisans who saw their work as a form of worship. The wealth and effort poured into these structures were not for human glory but to glorify the Creator. As Saint John Paul II observed, “Man needs beauty as well as bread.” This feast acknowledges the Church’s role in providing both material assistance to the poor and spiritual nourishment through beauty. 


The Basilicas dedicated to Saint Peter and Saint Paul are not just towering landmarks in Rome; they are deeply connected to the lives and martyrdom of two of the most important apostles in Christian history. But beyond their historical significance, these buildings serve as symbols of the Catholic Church's enduring strength, its apostolic foundation, and its connection to the eternal reality. 


Furthermore, the Feast of Dedication highlights the enduring role of sacred spaces in the life of the Church. These basilicas are places where generations of Christians have encountered God, celebrated the sacraments, and deepened their faith. The art and architecture within these spaces have the power to transcend time, speaking to our hearts across centuries. This enduring legacy reminds us that faith is not confined to a single moment or generation but is passed down through the living tradition of the Church. 


Finally, this feast challenges us to consider our own relationship with beauty and worship. It invites us to reflect on how sacred art and architecture can inspire us to grow in faith and charity. By celebrating the dedication of these basilicas, we are reminded of the importance of creating spaces that lift our hearts to God and deepen our understanding of His presence in the world. 


The Importance of Saint Peter and Saint Paul in Christianity 


Saint Peter and Saint Paul stand as two of the most pivotal figures in Christianity, shaping the early Church and leaving an enduring legacy of faith and mission. Their journeys, vastly different yet profoundly complementary, reveal the transformative power of God’s grace. From Saint Peter’s humble beginnings as an illiterate fisherman to his role as the leader of the apostles, and from Saint Paul’s zealous persecution of Christians to his mission to the Gentiles, both were guided by the Holy Spirit to fulfil God’s will. Together, they represent the unity and diversity of the Church’s mission. 


Saint Peter, originally named Simon, was an ordinary fisherman from Galilee. He was uneducated and often impulsive, a man who stumbled in both words and actions. His flaws are evident in the Gospels: he misunderstands Jesus’ teachings, sinks in the water when his faith falters, and, most poignantly, denies Christ three times during His Passion. Yet, despite these failings, Jesus saw Peter’s potential and chose him to be the rock upon which He would build His Church. This divine choice highlights a central truth of Christianity: God does not call the perfect but perfects those He calls. Peter’s life is a testament to God’s mercy and the transformative power of grace. 


Jesus entrusted him with the “keys of the kingdom of heaven,” granting him authority to guide and govern the Church (Matthew 16:19). This authority established Peter as the first pope, symbolising the unity and continuity of the Church. Empowered by the Holy Spirit at Pentecost, Peter became a bold and fearless leader. He preached the Gospel to thousands, healed the sick, and performed miracles in Christ’s name.  Despite his humble origins and earlier failures, Peter faithfully fulfilled his mission, ultimately laying down his life as a martyr in Rome. His story is a powerful reminder that God can use even the weakest among us to achieve His divine purposes. 


In contrast to Peter, Saint Paul, originally named Saul, began as a man of privilege and education. Born a Roman citizen in Tarsus and trained as a Pharisee, Saul was steeped in Jewish law and tradition. His zeal for the faith led him to persecute Christians, believing them to be a threat to Judaism. Saul’s fervour reached its peak with his involvement in the stoning of Saint Stephen. However, his encounter with the risen Christ on the road to Damascus changed everything. Struck blind and brought to his knees, Saul heard the voice of Jesus: “Saul, Saul, why are you persecuting me?” (Acts 9:4). This moment marked the beginning of his transformation from persecutor to apostle. 


Renamed Paul, he became one of Christianity’s greatest evangelists and theologians. Guided by the Holy Spirit, Paul embarked on numerous missionary journeys, spreading the Gospel to the Gentiles and establishing churches throughout the Roman Empire. His letters, many of which are included in the New Testament, provide profound insights into the faith and remain foundational to Christian theology. Paul’s intellect and passion enabled him to bridge the gap between Jewish and Gentile converts, articulating the universality of the Gospel message: that salvation is available to all through faith in Jesus Christ. Like Peter, Paul ultimately gave his life for the faith, also martyred in Rome under Emperor Nero. 


The complementary missions of Peter and Paul underscore the unity and diversity of the Church. Peter’s ministry focused on shepherding the Jewish Christian community and establishing the Church’s structural foundation, while Paul’s mission expanded its reach to the Gentiles, embracing cultural and theological diversity. Together, they represent the Church’s dual vocation to maintain unity in doctrine and governance while reaching out to all nations with the Gospel. Their shared martyrdom in Rome cements their legacy as the pillars of the Church, symbolising its universality and steadfastness. 


The lives of Saint Peter and Saint Paul remind us that God can use anyone, regardless of their background, to achieve His purposes. Peter, the unlearned fisherman who often stumbled, became the leader of the apostles and the keeper of the keys of the kingdom. Paul, the persecutor of Christians, became the great missionary to the Gentiles and a voice for Christ to the nations. Their stories inspire us to trust in God’s transformative power and to remain open to the guidance of the Holy Spirit as we seek to fulfil our own unique missions in the Church. Through their example, we see that God’s grace is sufficient to overcome all weaknesses and to bring about His glory through our lives. 


Conclusion 


The Feast of the Dedication of the Basilicas of Saint Peter and Saint Paul is a celebration deeply tied to the lives and missions of these two towering figures of Christianity. These basilicas, built over the tombs of the apostles, serve as physical and spiritual reminders of their unwavering faith and sacrifice for the Church. They stand as monuments to the unity and diversity that Saints Peter and Paul represent: Peter, the steadfast shepherd who nurtured the early Christian community, and Paul, the passionate missionary who spread the Gospel to the ends of the earth. 


This feast not only honours the architectural wonders of these sacred spaces but also invites us to reflect on the spiritual legacy of Saints Peter and Paul. Their lives demonstrate the transformative power of God’s grace, showing us that no past failure or sin is beyond redemption. Through their example, we are reminded of the Church’s mission to unite all people in faith, hope, and love. The basilicas serve as places of worship, teaching, and pilgrimage, helping generations of Christians to encounter God and to draw inspiration from the lives of these great apostles. 


As we celebrate this feast, we are called to renew our commitment to the faith they proclaimed and to follow their example of boldness, humility, and trust in the Holy Spirit. Just as Saints Peter and Paul were living stones in the foundation of the Church, we too are called to build up the Body of Christ in our time. Their enduring legacy, enshrined in these basilicas, reminds us of the beauty and strength of the Church that continues to proclaim Christ to the world. 

 

Resources:


1) “Peter: Keys to Following Jesus” by Tim Gray


This accessible yet profound book delves into the life of Saint Peter, exploring his transformation from a simple fisherman to the leader of the Church. It draws on Scripture and tradition to highlight Peter's significance and relevance for Christians today. Read more here.


2) "Paul, Apostle of Christ” (2018)


Starring Jim Caviezel and James Faulkner, this inspiring film depicts the final days of Saint Paul’s life as he reflects on his journey of faith. It is a powerful narrative of redemption and mission, capturing Paul’s unwavering commitment to Christ even in the face of persecution. Watch it here.


3) "The Passion of the Christ” (2004)


Directed by Mel Gibson, this iconic film focuses on the Passion of Jesus but prominently includes Peter’s denial and subsequent repentance, highlighting his humanity and journey towards becoming the leader of the apostles. Watch it here.

 

 Affiliate Disclosure: These products contain affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. Thank you for your support!

12 views0 comments

Related Posts

See All

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page